A question on War
Michael A. Chance
mchance at crl.com
Mon Jul 17 16:44:23 PDT 1995
> >Diarmuit asks:
> >This is sort of a simple question, and I suppose ties into to the
> >whole Ideal Event/Fighting thing, but why do we keep getting involved
> >in so many wars? I can understand a big annual thing, or even
> >a couple of big annual things, but how many wars is Ansteorra
> >currently involved in right now?
> Because they are fun? I enjoy fighting in war far more than I do in
> tournament, as most people who know me can tell you.
Personally, I believe one of the main reasons for the preference for
"wars" or similar primarily melee events is that more inexperience or
less talented folks get a lot more opportunities to compete. In the
typical SCA tourney, the "double elim", full half of the entrants only
get 2 or 3 fights before being eliminated. Frankly, given that (a)
only the best get any significant number of bouts and (b) that style
of tourney is, at best, a hundered years out of period (and I've yet
to see a firm reference any earlier than the late 18th century), it
truly amazes me that it's still the most commonly preferred tourney
Most true medieval and Renaissance tourney formats offer _lots_ more
bouts for each contestant. Want "fun" tournies? Ditch the
single/double elim format.
Michael A. Chance St. Louis, Missouri, USA "At play in the fields
Work: mc307a at sw1stc.sbc.com of St. Vidicon"
Play: mchance at crl.com
More information about the Ansteorra