Arts and Sciences Competition
Steve Hendricks
SteveH at wayne.com
Thu Oct 26 09:43:00 PDT 1995
Maire writes:
>Sorry, but the decision about the performance competition was made by the
>Kingdom A+S minister and NOT the autocrat for Kingdom A+S, I think you
>owe an apology
>
> you may want to email the person responsible directly:
> Master Thomas of Tenby: SERE55A at prodigy.com
I must ask forgiveness of the Kingdom A&S autocrat. I do not mean to
disparage them in any way (actually I do not mean to disparage anybody in
any way). I do not think the idea of having the musicians judged by the
Crown is a terrible idea, I merely think that music should be judged
similarly to the other A&S. Now, I believe a conscientious Crown will get
advisors (as per Sir Kein and Master Cynric) to aid them in their decisions.
So perhaps the point is moot. Just have all the competitions judged by the
Crown and all will be fair again (or at least equal).
A couple of people mentioned that music *should* be judged by popular
opinion. I submit to you that this is blatantly unfair. If I want to win
purely on the popularity of performance, I would play a lot of 18th century
Celtic ballads. These seem to be very popular in the SCA (and at
Renaissance festivals - sorry, pet peave) and would certainly go a long way
toward pleasing a lot of people.
And, sorry, I did not mention in my last posting that a "boring" but
technically difficult piece would lose to a lively, wonderful piece.
"Boring" is a very subjective word. I have heard many pieces that may have
seemed a bit lackluster at first hearing them (example - The Bothy Band's
"The Death of Queen Jane") that now bring tears to my eyes. Music is very
susceptible to one's mood. If you are in a party mood, "Louie, Louie" would
probably excite you more than *any* period song, especially any love song or
pious ballad. But I'm still not going to play it for you. I hope you
understand. After all, I still don't know the words.
Now, a certain person also responded to my mentioning that we would be doing
some carols at the next Bryn Gwlad Music Guild in preparation for our Yule
Revel. He objected to Christian music in rather strong terms.
Well, considering that most music was written down in the middle ages by
monks, it is somewhat more difficult to find music worshipping pagan gods.
I keep looking for druid songs carved into trees, but they seem to have not
survived. Fortunately, some of the monks were into sex, drugs and
rock'n'roll, so we have some secular songs that survived from them. Also we
have the troubadors and trouveres, but they were, by and large, Christians
also. So we have secular songs, but not many non-Christian sacred songs.
Besides, if they are performed in middle or old English, French, Latin,
German, Spanish, etc, how do you know they are not about the Norse gods? As
long as we are pretending to be in the Middle Ages, you can pretend that,
too. Perhaps we could even wear those funny viking hats with horns when we
sing.
As a non-Christian, I have learned to take the overflow of Christmas music
from Halloween on with a pillar of salt. But, as a dedicated musician, I
plan to distribute period music that many will never have heard. And, of
course, some that people have heard and did not know were that old. I still
cannot decide about "Good King Wenceslas," which was a medieval Spring song
"Adeste floridum" or something like that.
Of course, I will not be playing to the popular taste by omitting all those
Victorian carols that some will want to hear. Thank goodness we will not be
in a popular competition.
Darned if you do and darned if you don't, eh?
Still yours in musical service,
Samuel
steveh at austin.wayne.com
More information about the Ansteorra
mailing list