ES - Defender

[Donald Riney]

so, basicaly what we are saying is not the elimination of artistic merit 
in the judjing but rather the increased weight of the technical 
scores... Right??
<snip>

>The recent Gulf Wars brought out the fact  that Ansteorran artisans'
>documentation could be better.  This is where most artisan's lost 
>points in the competition.  The items/articles displayed were good, 
>the documentation was good.  but the documentation could have been 
>better.  Ideally, without judging the workmanship of the item, the 
>documentation should be good enough to judge the article.  It would 
>include how the article would have been made, how the artisan made 
>it, what was different such as I used a modern tool that I bought 
>instead of making the tool that would have been used, etc.
>
>Once again, this is just speculation at this point, nothing has been 
>put together, no consensus has been reached.  Just my (mis) 
>conception of what we were dicussing.
>
>
>
>
>Meistres Eowyn ferch Rhys
>Barony of Elfsea, Ansteorra  (Fort Worth, Texas)
>Central Regional Seneschal
>e-mail:  Phyllis.Spurr at tdh.state.tx.us
>office phone:  (817) 264-4384
>home phone:    (817) 460-1539
>============================================================================
>Go to http://www.ansteorra.org/lists.html to perform mailing list 
tasks.
>


______________________________________________________
Get Your Private, Free Email at http://www.hotmail.com
============================================================================
Go to http://www.ansteorra.org/lists.html to perform mailing list tasks.