HNW - TI article rejected! :-(

Irene Davis idavis at
Mon Apr 6 23:09:16 PDT 1998

Greetings Kathryn!
>Would you believe it was because my article was too scholarly???? :-O  
>seems that TI is trying to become a journal that encourages how-to 

I find this amazingly ironic since my greatest complaint about TI has 
often been its lack of scholarly accuracy! Do it yourself is fine, and 
I love those kind of articles, but how can you "do it" and be 
moderately accurate if you don't have the scholarly research?!?! It 
reminds me of a gorgeous "viking tunic" that I saw this past weekend. 
The cuffs, collar and bottom edge of the tunic were embroidered in a 
lovely pattern, in a classic Viking style. The only problem was that 
the tunic was made of a white fuzzy knit polyester fabric. The handwork 
was gorgeous, but the fabric! Someone actually had the ----- to enter 
this in an A&S competition. I couldn't believe it! Thank God it did not 
win! I wish there was a scholarly journal for SCA research, where 
people who want to know what was really going on could submit and 
publish real research!

Yours in Service,

Eirny Thorvaldsdottir

To be removed from the Historic Needlework mailing list, please send a
message to Majordomo at Ansteorra.ORG with the message body of "unsubscribe

More information about the H-needlework mailing list