[ANSTHRLD] Hello?? (was "Conflict Checks (2)")

[Jim Trigg]

On Wed, June 22, 2005 9:39 am, Ron said:
>>
>> 1) Gyronny arrondi of six Or and gules, an orle sable.
>
> Closest I found was:
>
> Frithiof Sigvardsson Skägge
> Drachenwald 09/96
> Gyronny argent and vert, an orle sable.
>
> I count one CD for X.4.ii.b:
> "(b) Complete Change of Tincture  - If the fields of two pieces of
> field-primary armory have no tinctures in common, they are considered
> completely different and do not conflict, irrespective of any other
> similarities between them."
>
> I don't believe there is another CD for X.4.ii.a:
> "(a) Substantial Change of Partition  - If two pieces of field-primary
> armory have substantially different partitions, they are considered
> sufficiently different and do not conflict, irrespective of any other
> similarities between them."
>
> Someone else may be able to clarify is I'm right.

X.4.a.ii.a and X.4.a.ii.b are special cases within X.4 which do not deal
with CDs but with substantial difference (as in X.2).  Note the phrase
"completely different and do not conflict, irrespective of any other
similarities between them".  This is clear of the proposed armory by
X.4.a.ii.b.

I also found a couple of items that were clear by exactly two CDs, but no
potential conflicts.

>> 2) Per fess dancetty purpure and argent, a turtle counterchanged.
>
> Closest I found was:
>
> Elizabet Fergus Morrison
> Outlands 11/99
> Per bend wavy azure and argent, a turtle counterchanged.
>
> I count one CD for X.4.a, field differences, and one for X.4.d, tincture
> changes.

Just to nitpick (I am a herald, after all), that should be "X.4.a.i".

Blaise
-- 
Jim Trigg, Lord High Everything Else  O-  /"\
SKA Seigneur Blaise de Cormeilles         \ /  ASCII RIBBON CAMPAIGN
Silver Nautilus Herald, Atlantia           X    HELP CURE HTML MAIL
Webmaster, Academy of S. Gabriel          / \