[ANSTHRLD] Conflict Question

[Brian O'hUilliam]

Thanks, that's what I *thought* it meant.  Back to the drawing board.

Brian


On 5/15/07, Britt <tierna.britt at gmail.com> wrote:
>
> > The RfS states: *X.4.j.i. *
> > *   j. Changes to Charges on Charges* - Changes to a group of charges
> placed
> > entirely on other charges may create one clear difference.
> >
> > No more than one clear difference can be obtained from changes to the
> same
> > group of charges on other charges.
> >
> > *i.* Making two or more visually significant changes to the same group
> of
> > charges placed entirely on other charges is one clear difference.
> >
> > Changes of type, number, tincture, posture, or independent changes of
> > arrangement may each count as one of the two changes.
> >
> >
> > I am having a little trouble interpreting this text.  I look at it two
> ways,
> > but I think the first is correct:
> > *Interp 1:*  I can only get one CD from the green shamrock versus the
> blue
> > fox even though they are substantially different (paraphrasing Daniel:
> RfS
> > X.4.j.ii allows a substantial difference in type in simple cases to get
> a CD
> > all on its own.) and the tinctures are different.  I am looking at the
> > sentence under the deinition of X.4.j.
> > *Interp 2:*  I get 1 CD for the tincture of the tertiary charge and
> another
> > CD for the substantial difference of the tertiary charge.  I am looking
> at
> > the second sentence of X.4.j.i.
>
> The Rule is clear. No matter how many changes are made to a group of
> charges entirely on other charges, the most you can ever count is a
> CD.
> You get that CD by X.4.j.i. by changing type and tincture of the
> tertiary charge. OR you get that CD by X.4.j.ii. by changing type only
> from shamrock to fox. But you only get one.  The whole of X.4.j. is
> beneath the sentence, "No more than one clear difference can be
> obtained from changes to the same group of charges on other charges,"
> which governs the subsections.
>
> - Teceangl
> _______________________________________________
> Heralds mailing list
> Heralds at lists.ansteorra.org
> http://lists.ansteorra.org/listinfo.cgi/heralds-ansteorra.org
>