SC - authenticity
Varju at aol.com
Varju at aol.com
Thu May 13 10:05:05 PDT 1999
In a message dated 5/12/1999 11:48:31 PM Mountain Daylight Time,
redbear at hollinet.com writes:
<< The problem with recreating the middle ages and the varying aspects
thereof is that it was not a highly literate society and much of what was
written down is no longer extant. This is especially true of cooking, often
an oral tradition. If we randomly create recipes, we are not recreating the
middle ages. However, if we only use extant recipes, we are not recreating
the middle ages, as so much has ben lost. >>
I feel compelled to respond here, which is probably a combination of lack of
sleep and too strong of coffeee. :->
In my time on this wonderful list I have learned many things. One is that
there is a wealth of sources of period recipies. The problem is not a lack
of them, except for a few times and places, but a lack of people redactiong
and the ever present language problem. Like so many other aspects of our
period of study I think it is a big myth that much knowledge was "lost". we
just haven't gotten around to translating it. This does not mean that
creating a recipie using "educated guesses" is going to make it period any
more than using period language in a freestyle poem will make it a period
piece of poetry. (And this from the person who still likes using paprika. :->)
I have made these sort of "educated guesses" in other aspects of my SCA
life, my garb for instance, and I reconize that I may have guessed right or
wrong to varying degrees. It still doesn't make it authentic or accurate, it
remains my attempt based on my research, and I would never label it
absolutely period. By the same token, why would I label a recipie created in
the same manner period?
I think Master Adamantius's fictional account gives us an idea how far off
track this sort of thinking can take us and it is a scary picture. (I think I
need more coffee after that :->)
Noemi
half awake and hungery. . .
Windkeep Outlands
Cheyenenne, WY
============================================================================
To be removed from the SCA-Cooks mailing list, please send a message to
Majordomo at Ansteorra.ORG with the message body of "unsubscribe SCA-Cooks".
============================================================================
More information about the Sca-cooks
mailing list