SC - Haggis and Strawberries
Susan Fox-Davis
selene at earthlink.net
Mon Aug 21 12:34:46 PDT 2000
Lady Katherine McGuire wrote:
> There was an incident, at another group's Imperial War last year. A entry
> was made of a strawberry jam, I would have called it a compote. As part of
> the documentation there was a quote from a on line dictionary that stated
> that a strawberry was found that was as "big as Queen Elizabeth's head" and
> the date was given as 1565.
If the cutoff date for the Adrian Empire is 1500, that indeed would not qualify
as acceptable documentation. I commend this page as an in-depth yet accessible
source on the history of the Strawberry:
<http://www.nal.usda.gov/pgdic/Strawberry/book/bokthree.htm>
> Now in my opinion, this is a error. I looked up the reference but could
> not find it. Maybe it was my bad computer skills or? But in the same A/S
> tournament there was an entry of strawberry cordual. In this documentation
> it was stated that the average size of strawberries, in the period, were
> about the size of the a women's thumb nail. The entrant had used the varity
> of wild strawberries available, and had gone out of her way to make the
> entry as "period" as possible.
> The first entrant was "upset" that her jam did not beat the cordual, and
> kept saying that it needed to be rejudged. This was deigned by the person
> running the tournament, on the grounds that the judges were all A/S Knights
> equivalent to Laurels in the SCA.
Phooey, I've gotten upset with Adrian arts judging to the point where I won't
compete at all. What part of 'primary source' don't these people get? *sigh*
Well, I agree that the judging was probably correct in the first place, but
better they should have cited weak documentation, if that was the case. Mind
you, I don't enter contests in the SCA much either, I run them instead.
Selene Colfox, in either game
selene at earthlink.net
More information about the Sca-cooks
mailing list