SC - Be Nice to Cariadoc Week

[Elaine Koogler]

I believe it was a public post in response to a reply that I made from a query
about the Baghdad Cookery Book.  I stated that it was part of Cariadoc's
Collection of cookbooks, and was told by this gentle that it wasn't...and the rest
of his commentary you have seen.

Sorry if I precipitated such a diatribe, but I was merely trying to respond to a
query.

Kiri

"Michael F. Gunter" wrote:

> > Sayyid Suleyman al Rashid ibn Beyazid,
> >     Proud Ottoman Turk skrev:
> >
> > >    I have a problem with Cariadoc anyway.
>
> > >   (A view which is common in society as a whole, unfortunately.)
> >
> > Yes, he has his weaknesses, but I hardly think that this List, or any other,
> > is the right place to argue them without providing specific quotes from him,
> > with specific documentation to refute his statements or his assertions.
> > Let's deal with the evidence, please folks, and let personalities slide.
> >
> > Phlip the Currently Saintly
>
> Was the first post part of the list? I must have missed it because I know that
> I would jump all over anyone making such statements on my list. If you wish
> to slam or flame any member of my list it had better be in a private mail and
> not publicly posted. If this was a private post and Philip posted it to the
> list
> then she had better hope it was done accidently. I'll not have such slanderous
> and reactionary comments allowed in any way on this list. As a matter of
> record, His Grace has earned his notable respect through years of fighting the
> current of public opinion and disinterest. His scholarship is solid and the
> effort he puts into trying to make the SCA a more realistic place as well as
> his work to make period cookery a reality instead of a mockery deserves
> proper respect. I will admit that he comes across as a bit harsh sometimes
> and I've reminded him of this at times. He has changed his manner on this
> list and been quite charming. I have never seen him deliberately slam or
> insult anyone as the first posting did to him.
>
> If I see another post like the first quoted on this list, or if a private post
> is
> publicly posted the offender will be banned.
>
> I'm getting tired of being the big meany lately. Please people, use some
> logic and courtesy.
>
> Gunthar
>
> ============================================================================
>
> To be removed from the SCA-Cooks mailing list, please send a message to
> Majordomo at Ansteorra.ORG with the message body of "unsubscribe SCA-Cooks".
>
> ============================================================================