SCA award system revisions
Aodhan Ite an Fhithich
aodhan at dobharchu.org
Thu Oct 24 22:40:49 PDT 1996
"Mark Harris" wrote in a message to All:
"H> Why is the Order of the Rose here? Or at least why isn't it for
"H> "exceptional retiring rulers by right of arms"?
Well, I did say this proposal wasn't perfect...
"H> Why should the
"H> royalty automatically become members of this order when the
"H> Court Barony is only given for exceptional service?
There is a distinction between Barons-in-Fief and Rulers-by-Right-of-Arms -
*anyone* can become the former if they:
- Live in a Barony
- Are sufficiently popular with the Crown
- Are sufficiently popular with the Barony's populace
I *can* become Baron of Loch Soilleir (although two attempts so far have not
been successful, I can at least make the attempt); I *cannot* become King of
Ansteorra (since I don't fight and neither does my wife).
I *think* this distinction is important enough to SCA folk to merit
recognition, even though former kings in the middle ages tended to be in either
exile or the grave.
"H> I feel many barons/ess have put in more service although spread
"H> over years instead of six months than some crowns. The crown
"H> already gets a lot of this acknowledgement and word fame we are
"H> talking about.
Barons-in-Fief are really just extra-fancy officers. They do have some
ceremonial perks and responsibilities the other officers don't have, but that's
the nature of the office. Sometimes it's easy and sometimes it's hard - same
as any other office. However, I think being crown is an order of magnitude
more work than being baron - that's why we let them serve only 6 months but
expect barons to put in at least a couple of years. A regular officer who
served a minimal term with adequate performance probably doesn't deserve a
promotion (yet) - it's a function of time-in-grade and quality of work.
My Order of the Rose was, I guess, somewhat of a sop since I was taking away
County and Duchy. Maybe we could make all former Barons-in-Fief and former
Rulers-by-Right-of-Arms Court Barons.
This *was* a straw-man proposal. Feel free to kick it around and see where the
stuffing falls out.
More information about the Ansteorra