ANSTHRLD - Old submission (from 1995) query (& conflict check)

[Jennifer Smith]

An old submittor (or actually, his wife), gave me a call today, and is 
interested in trying to resurrect and resubmit a device he attempted to 
register back in 1995.  According to the *extremely useful* Index files kept 
by Daniel, Theodore Bernand Gardener's device was submitted in ILoI 3/95 
33, and returned in Kingdom in 5/95 (AG 8/95a).  My collection of 1995-era 
AGs is rather sparse; I don't have the 3/95 one, nor the 8/95 one, but the 
ICC was printed in the 6/95 AG, and gave no indication as to why the device 
might be returned.  According to the submittor's wife, it was returned for a 
redraw, on account of "the bear looked like a wolf."

Can someone help me find out why the device was indeed returned, and if it 
was just for a redraw, help me conflict check it?

The device is "Azure, a bear sejant erect argent within a border argent 
charged with eight daisies gules seeded Or." 

Everything *seems* clear, but I'm still pretty new to conflict checking.  I've 
assumed no CD between sejant erect, rampant, and erect (and statant 
erect?)

Small Grey Bear, Shire of the (Feb 1989): Azure, a bear argent within a 
laurel wreath Or, all between three compass stars argent.
	1 CD for removal of half the primary group (laurel wreath)? and another 
for change of type of secondary.  (And another for addition of tertiaries?)

Achsa of Beresford (May 1988): Azure, a bear rampant and in chief two 
fleams, all within a bordure argent.
	1 CD for removal of fleams, 1 CD for addition of tertiaries

Matthias von Würzburg (Jul 1999): Azure, a bear rampant and on a chief 
argent three seeblatter azure.
	1 CD for change of type of secondary, 1 CD for change of type & 
number & color of tertiaries (?)

Vaclav Semjaka (Dec 1990): Azure, a bear rampant and on a gore argent a 
mullet of three points gules.
	Ditto previous.

Brynach MacCallum (Aug 1985): Azure, a bear rampant argent vested in a 
fool's motley lozengy Or and gules, grasping in both forepaws a needle 
point to base Or.
	I'm guessing the fool's motley doesn't count as a CD.  I know there's 1 
CD for addition of the bordure; 1 for addition of the tertiaries?

Aleksandr Ivanovitch Budishchev (Sep 1992): Azure, a bear rampant 
between two flaunches argent, each charged with a bow, string to center 
sable.
	1 CD for change of type of secondary, and another CD for change of 
tertiaries

Alix de Coucy (Apr 1998): Azure, a bear statant erect muzzled, on a chief 
argent four retorts gules.
	1 CD for change of type of secondary, 1 CD for change of type and 
number of tertiaries?  (Whatever a 'retort' is...)

Leifr Beorn Hrolfsson (Aug 1998): Barry wavy azure and Or, a sea bear 
erect argent.
	1 CD for change of field, 1 CD for addition of secondary.

Gottfrid Liljebjörn (Sep 1986): Quarterly pean and purpure, a bear rampant 
within a bordure argent.
	1 CD for change of field, 1 CD for addition of tertiaries

There were several others, who effectively matched what I listed above.  Did 
I missing anything obvious?

-Emma de Fetherstan


--
Jennifer Smith
jds at randomgang.com
============================================================================
Go to http://lists.ansteorra.org/lists.html to perform mailing list tasks.