[Sca-cooks] Re: a GOOD book

Phlip phlip at 99main.com
Sun Nov 17 18:05:06 PST 2002


Devra skrev:

> By the way, the paper edition of the Oxford Companion to Food, by Alan
> Davidson--paper ed is called 'Penguin Companion', but who's quibbling? is
now
> available for $30.  A real bargain.  If people think they're interested, I
> will add it to my inventory.
> Devra the semi-retired

A word of caution, folks. While many of the articles in it are good,
several are...less than what one might expect from a collection bearing the
Oxford name. Paul Buell says that the section on Mongolian food is highly
inaccurate, and that to be very careful of any bearing Alan Davidson's name.
His scholarship tends to be...less than outstanding. Please use your
educated judgement when reading it.

Phlip




More information about the Sca-cooks mailing list