[Sca-cooks] "Trial By Fire" Ad (cooking competition!)

[otsisto]

My comment had to do with being tired of the debate over the timeline.
It was not intended to amuse anyone. Nor make a joke or butt of a joke of
anything.
Phlip has a right to voice an irritation. I was merely pointing out
possibilities of their reasons and that the question(s) would be best
answered by asking the source of the rules.
If your post has little or nothing to do with my post then please in the
future select the one that you are commenting on.

Lyse
Who also is not amused


-----Original Message-----
Im really sorry that olwen put the silly damed thing on this list .It was
not ment to be the butt of jokes ,pokes or anyones deep seated hatreds Of
some one elses fun. Im angry as of now and am asking people to drop this
thred.please. Chirhart- no longer amused

otsisto <otsisto at socket.net> wrote:Okay, somewhere there is a vague (really
vague)reference to the starting
period as being "the fall of the Roman Empire" and the ending time at pre
17th century which means ending date Dec. 31, 1600. Therefore, it looks as
if they are catering, not to the SCA period but to some other timeline. They
grandfathered Apicius, which means they feel they are making a consetion by
allowing it.
Their contest, their rules. I'm sure you can approach them (calmly)and ask
for reasons why (timeline, why not Anthimus, etc).

Lyse
Who doesn't feel like pulling out the timeline info.