[Sca-cooks] 1421
Ann Sasahara
ariann at nmia.com
Wed Feb 26 09:06:00 PST 2003
Interestingly enough this debate has been going on for a few decades. In
1977, I was an Anthro undergrad at Univ of AZ, where my professors presented
a 'recent' China/Japan to Mesoamerica theory (Meggers and Evans, American
Anthropologist, 1977) as a possible theory for cultural diffusion in the
Americas My professors were Rathje (Cozumel Mayan site) and Culbert (Tikal
Mayan site), both prominent in Mesoamerican archaeology. So, when they
spoke, I heard the Word from on high and yeay, verrily, I believed the Word.
:) And the Word was that Orient-to- Mesoamerica diffusion was all
speculation, because it lacked hard archaeological evidence.
Now that decades of research have passed, there is a bit more evidence, but
I'm still rather skeptical -- it's hard to shake the influence of past profs
and mentors. For those who enjoy the topic, the following link is a
slightly-biased summary of the whole Fusang diffusion debate from day one:
http://hussle.harvard.edu/~zhang/docs/Pre-Columbian%20Contact.pdf
Aside: Potential cultural diffusion like this really makes one wonder about
'indigenous' foods. ;-)
Food for thought,
-Ariann
Libri tot, parum temporis....
----- Original Message -----
From: "Terry Decker" <t.d.decker at worldnet.att.net>
> While I find the Zuni thing questionable, there is a paper which
>describes a pottery comparison between an area in Japan and
>one on the West Coast. The unique simularities between the two
>pottery styles suggests cross contamination. The author speculates
>that the Japanese designs may have been introduced by a shipwrecked
>Japanese fisherman, a more believable scenario than an elusive
>expedition which leaves no trail.
More information about the Sca-cooks
mailing list