[Sca-cooks] Questions
Phil Troy / G. Tacitus Adamantius
adamantius.magister at verizon.net
Sun Nov 7 07:38:23 PST 2004
Also sprach Marcus Loidolt:
>Okay, I know I'm being lazy here, but I don't have
>alot of time at hand.
>
>How period are grilled steaks? Steaks of any other
>sort?
Steaks as slices of meat cut across the grain are eminently period.
They are often cooked using moist-heat methods, though, and are
sometimes described as being small. The recipe may say something
like, cut it into stekys of a hand's breadth.
However, late 16th and early 17th-century English sources refer to a
cooking method called, collectively, a carbonado (which is vastly
different from, say, Carbonade de Falamande, which is a stew made
with onions and beer, but also wonderful). Gervase Markham talks
about how to carbonado different foods at some length, and I believe
he mentions steaks among them -- also various items like boiled pig's
feet, the wings of poultry, small pieces of breast of lamb or veal,
veal chops, sausages, etc. The cooking apparatus is a sort of
vertical iron grill covered with little spikes or hooks, and you
stand the grill up next to the fire. The Elizabethans may have
preferred to avoid the smoky flavor of grilled meats, which may
explain their apparent fixation with wrapping certain foods in paper
before cooking, and cooking next to, rather than over, a fire. There
are also the logistics of cooking in a fireplace, rather than over an
open fire, to be considered.
Platina, writing in the 15th century, also mentions grilling small
pieces of meat over, I believe, charcoal.
>Where does Barbeque fit in?
Pit or grill?
> Is Oriental Barbeque
>different from Caribbean?
If I can ever find an Oriental who can tell me, conclusively, what
Oriental Barbecue is, I'll let you know. Until then I will assume it
is a Western marketing fad that is largely unknown in Asia. Don't get
me wrong, I'm not making fun of you, but even the term "Mongolian
Barbecue" (the term you're probably most likely to hear around my
neck of the woods) seems to mean whatever the speaker of the moment
wants it to mean.
I have recipes in Chinese cookbooks for Mongolian barbecue (which
don't seem very Mongolian to me, but what do I know?), and I've seen
photos from Western China of "Mongolian barbecue" being done both on
huge round griddles over a heat source, and on actual gridirons (the
bars placed more closely together than in your typical Weber grill,
no more than 1/2 inch apart, maybe) over a real fire. It seems to
generally involve lamb and leeks, and a sesame-seed-covered
roti/nan/lavosh type of bread.
In Mongolia, though, herdsmen will still occasionally cook with
stones heated in the fire, sealed, with the meat, in a container like
a clay jar or a steel milk can. Somewhere I actually have video
footage of this being done.
>How so? Are either one of
>them period for us?
I believe Columbus found the Caribs doing some form of grilling over
a smoky fire when he arrived. Some might argue this, but it sounds
pretty period.
>Is Caribbean Barbeque Native or would it have been
>brought from Africa with the slave trade?
I don't know for sure, but I think it's native and predates the slave trade.
Adamantius
--
"Why don't they get new jobs if they're unhappy -- or go on Prozac?"
-- Susan Sheybani, assistant to Bush campaign spokesman Terry
Holt, 07/29/04
"Who cares what you think?"
-- The President of the United States, 07/04/01
More information about the Sca-cooks
mailing list